‘The Traitors’ Season 3 Cast: The Famous Faces We Desperately Want to See

Monica won’t be returning to RHOSLC, which means she’ll go down as one of the most impactful one-season wonders in Housewives history. That she was able to keep a giant secret from her entire cast, all of production, millions of viewers, and Bravo itself—and the fact that she was one of the people behind an Instagram troll account and still made it into the show—makes her a perfect fit for The Traitors.

Boston Rob is one of the most legendary Survivor players of all time, having played five times—including one win and one runner-up run, in which he eventually lost to his wife, Amber. The couple also played The Amazing Race twice, placing second one of those times. Rob is hyper-competitive, disarming, and a great gamer, which makes him primed for the Traitors castle.

During her MTV run in the early- to mid-2000s, Kristin proved she wasn’t afraid to be the villain. Her mere presence stirred the pot—and she was never afraid of confrontation—which makes her a great candidate for The Traitors. It’s no secret that she wouldn’t be afraid to accuse someone of being a Traitor at the Roundtable.

Rachel will go down as one of the most memorable and history-making leads in Bachelor Nation history. Fresh off of a shocking divorce—and on top of her successful podcast, in which she analyzes Bravo shows—Rachel would bring an informed, level-headed presence to the show that could take her to the end as an effective Faithful.

There’s no question that Craig is compelling television, having been a staple throughout nine seasons of Bravo’s Charleston-set reality show, but we’ve yet to see him in a competition show setting. As a well-known tinfoil-hat-wearing conspiracy theorist, Craig could make for a highly entertaining Faithful with a competitive spirit to boot.

Da’Vonne is a three-time Big Brother competitor whose best placement was tenth place, but she’s made an even bigger impact as a beloved fan-favorite who’s the face of more than a few memes. She would bring humor and heart to the castle, winning over millions of more fans in the process.

What better way to follow up a solid career in the NFL than with an appearance in an entirely different—but no less cutthroat—competitive environment? By joining The Traitors, Jason would have the opportunity to continue winning the hearts of America fresh off of his retirement announcement. We know he has heart, making him an ideal Faithful candidate.

As one of the most notorious villains in reality TV history, Spencer is made for this show. Making him a Traitor is the obvious choice, because you just know he would find a way to snake his way out of the sights of the Faithfuls while still stealing the spotlight. The epitome of a reality TV pro.

If you have Spencer, you also need Heidi. Otherwise, you wouldn’t get Speidi! Season 2 gave us a short-lived experiment of casting known couple Marcus Jordan and Larsa Pippen, but Marcus was murdered early, robbing viewers of seeing how the dynamic would play out. Putting both Spencer and Heidi on the show together would provide an even more riveting version of that experiment.

Taylor made history when she won Big Brother season 24, a win made even more impressive by the fact that she was bullied and outcast by her competitors early in the season. She powered through, proving to be an adept competitor and social gamer, ultimately winning not only just the game but also the title of “America’s Favorite Houseguest.” A certified fan-favorite, Taylor would be a total Faithful magnet and incredibly fun to watch.

I mean, could you imagine the outfits alone? Christine’s divisive run on Netflix’s West Hollywood-set soapy real estate show, Selling Sunset, came to an end a few seasons ago, making her a free agent. It would be interesting to see her in a completely different setting, test whether she could also intimidate reality stars from other arenas, and watch how she handles a Roundtable (especially since she skipped her last Selling Sunset reunion).

Stassi is a huge reason why early Pump Rules seasons made for such iconic reality TV. While she was eventually fired from the show in disgrace, she has since owned up to her mistakes and is due for a return to the medium. Famously outspoken and obsessed with murder mysteries, Stassi would lean into the campiness of the show—and you can just see her eating someone alive at a Roundtable.

Perhaps one of the most book-smart contestants to ever play Survivor, John proved his reality TV competition bonafides when he won the show on his second go around. The Columbia University and Harvard Law graduate would bring intellect and nerdiness charm to the Traitors castle, but is that enough to get someone to the end? Let’s find out, Peacock, shall we?

Tiffany was the mastermind behind one of the most ingenious alliances in reality TV history when she formed “The Cookout” on season 23 of Big Brother. The groundbreaking, six-person group was formed during the first week of the competition, in the hopes of producing the show’s first-ever Black winner. The fact that all six of them outlasted their competitors to successfully make it to the top six and deliver on their mission speaks to the vision that Tiffany had. Who knows what she could come up with inside the Traitors castle, but we’d absolutely love to see it.

Scott being on a show like The Traitors would probably prove to be stunt casting—and he likely wouldn’t end up being much of a factor—but…what if he were? This would be his opportunity to surprise viewers, make a star-making run far into the game, and step back into the spotlight in a big way. Hey, you never know!

Marlo recently announced that she wouldn’t be returning to RHOA, which makes this a prime opportunity for her to jump into another reality TV universe. She’d bring the fashion, the reads, and her undeniable X factor.

Carson has been a constant presence on TV since the debut of the original Queer Eye two decades ago, and he’s never skipped a beat on screen. He would bring irresistible humor and charm to the castle that would totally disarm his competitors—which could actually make him an unsuspected Traitor.

Traitors are heeeerrreeee!!! We all know and love Snooki, a mononymous reality star for the ages. It would be oh so intriguing to see how she would operate inside the Traitors castle: Would she be hilariously tapped out or would she be unexpectedly locked in? The only way to find out is to send her over to Scotland.

The Peloton cycling instructor with an outsize, infectious personality would be hard to ignore in the Traitors castle, even if he wound up being one of the few non-reality stars in the cast. Something tells us that Cody would make for a fierce competitor during the missions and at the Roundtable.

Meghan’s name is often brought up in Bravo circles when Real Housewives find themselves in detective mode, trying to uncover the truth about their co-stars. In fact, she’s largely credited as one of the first to put on her detective hat and rightly question Brooks Ayers’ claim that he had cancer—making us wonder how she would fare as a Faithful trying to pinpoint the truth about who among her is a Traitor.