We Tried Top-Rated Items From Celebrity Skincare Lines, And Here’s What We Thought

Here’s what we thought:

This one smelled delicious…almost like Fruity Pebbles or Scooby Doo fruit snacks, but like…better. The moisturizer itself has a slight pink hue, which kind of made me feel like I was spreading calamine lotion on my body, but I digress. It absorbed into the skin well, and the packaging was super simple and sleek, which I loved. Better yet, it’s REFILLABLE! This is one of the only ones with a pump, which I prefer because it helps me preserve product and not use too much. This one feels the most “expensive” to me, just from the packaging alone. —Sarah

This packaging feels PREMIUM, and the refill-of-it-all is very cool. Also dig that the pump doesn’t over-pump (and waste) product. Will say, however, that the pink color is kinda strange! Fruity, floral scent that’s very detectable, and the product itself feels very, very light on the skin. Probably the thinnest of all the products I’ve tested so far. Smell got kind of odd, but not off-putting, as I let it sit on my skin, though. Something about this is giving RiRi, but I can’t explain that thought process. I love that there’s SPF, but it DOES NOT apply or feel like sunscreen!!!! —Ross

I actually really liked the packaging (maybe my favorite of the bunch, and it’s a convenient pump for at-home use), and that’s about it. It’s way too liquid-y in my opinion, and the color is what I can only call “calamine lotion pink.” The smell was fine. —Jen

I really like how this one smells — it’s almost like sweet/candy-like. It feels ever so slightly greasy, but it’s still super light which is nice. The packaging is amazing — I love that it’s a pump rather than a jar (for sanitary reasons). And it’s refillable?! Incredible. —Claudia

Wait, I kinda love this one? The packaging is really sleek, and I love the little twist-up top. It feels like I’m getting a pretty decent amount of product, like if I used this day and night, it’d def last me a few months. I also just love the smell of this one, it’s so fruity but not so overpowering that it makes me wanna vom. —Lauren